Jeep Compass MK or MP: Comprehensive Analysis and Comparison

The Jeep Compass has undergone significant changes from its first generation (MK) to the current second generation (MP). This article provides a detailed comparison of both models, focusing on performance, design, features, and overall value.

Jeep Compass MK vs MP: Key Differences

The Jeep Compass transitioned from the MK to MP generation in 2017, bringing substantial improvements across various aspects:

• Design: The MP generation features a more modern and refined exterior design, closely resembling its larger sibling, the Grand Cherokee. In contrast, the MK had a more dated appearance.
• Interior Quality: The MP generation saw a significant upgrade in interior materials and build quality, addressing one of the major criticisms of the MK model.
• Technology: The MP introduced advanced infotainment systems and driver assistance features, bringing the Compass up to par with modern competitors.
• Performance: While both generations offer capable powertrains, the MP generation improved overall refinement and efficiency.

Performance and Powertrain Options

MK Generation (2007-2016)

The first-generation Compass offered several engine options throughout its lifespan:

• 2.0L World Engine: 158 hp, 141 lb-ft of torque
• 2.4L World Engine: 172 hp, 165 lb-ft of torque
• 2.2L Mercedes-Benz OM651: 161 hp, 236 lb-ft of torque (diesel, select markets)

Transmission options included a 5-speed manual, CVT, and 6-speed automatic. The MK generation was criticized for its lackluster performance and refinement, especially with the CVT option.

MP Generation (2017-present)

The current Compass offers more modern and efficient powertrains:

• 1.3L FireFly Turbo: 130-150 hp, 199-199 lb-ft of torque
• 2.0L Multijet II Diesel: 170 hp, 258 lb-ft of torque
• 2.4L Tigershark: 180 hp, 175 lb-ft of torque (North America)
• 2.0L Hurricane Turbo: 200 hp, 221 lb-ft of torque (2023+ North America)

Transmission options now include a 6-speed manual, 6-speed automatic, and 9-speed automatic. The MP generation offers improved performance and efficiency across the board.

“The new 2.0L Hurricane engine in the 2023+ Compass is a game-changer, offering smooth power delivery and improved fuel economy compared to the old 2.4L Tigershark.”[1]

Design and Styling

MK Generation

The first-generation Compass featured a design that was controversial among Jeep enthusiasts:

• Softer, more car-like styling
• Less pronounced Jeep design cues
• Criticized for lacking the rugged Jeep character

MP Generation

The current Compass adopted a more premium and distinctly Jeep-like appearance:

• Styling inspired by the Grand Cherokee
• More aggressive front fascia with the iconic seven-slot grille
• Improved proportions and stance

“The MP generation Compass finally looks like a proper Jeep, with a design that could easily be mistaken for a baby Grand Cherokee.”[2]

Interior Quality and Features

MK Generation

The interior of the first-generation Compass was often criticized for its quality and features:

• Hard plastics and budget-feeling materials
• Basic infotainment systems
• Limited advanced safety features

MP Generation

The current Compass saw a significant upgrade in interior quality and technology:

• Soft-touch materials and improved build quality
• Available 10.1-inch Uconnect 5 infotainment system
• Digital instrument cluster options
• Advanced driver assistance features

“The interior of the new Compass is night and day compared to the old model. It feels like a proper premium compact SUV now.”[3]

Off-Road Capability

Both generations of the Compass offer some level of off-road capability, but there are notable differences:

MK Generation

• Available Freedom Drive I (light-duty AWD) and Freedom Drive II (more capable 4WD) systems
• Limited off-road prowess compared to other Jeep models

MP Generation

• Improved Jeep Active Drive and Active Drive Low 4×4 systems
• Selec-Terrain traction management system
• Trailhawk trim offers genuine off-road capability

The MP generation, especially in Trailhawk trim, is significantly more capable off-road than its predecessor.

Fuel Economy

Fuel efficiency has improved from the MK to MP generation:

MK Generation

• 2.0L FWD: Up to 23 mpg city / 30 mpg highway
• 2.4L 4WD: Up to 21 mpg city / 27 mpg highway

MP Generation

• 1.3L Turbo FWD: Up to 31 mpg city / 35 mpg highway
• 2.0L Turbo 4WD: Up to 24 mpg city / 32 mpg highway

The MP generation offers improved fuel economy across the board, especially with the new turbocharged engines.

Safety Features and Ratings

MK Generation

The first-generation Compass had limited advanced safety features and received mixed safety ratings:

• Standard front and side airbags
• Available electronic stability control
• NHTSA: 3-star overall rating (2011 model year)

MP Generation

The current Compass offers significantly improved safety features and ratings:

• Standard Forward Collision Warning and Automatic Emergency Braking
• Available Adaptive Cruise Control, Lane Departure Warning, and Blind Spot Monitoring
• NHTSA: 4-star overall rating (2023 model year)
• IIHS: Top Safety Pick (2022 model year with specific headlights)

Pricing and Value

The pricing strategy for the Compass has evolved between generations:

MK Generation

• Starting price (2016 model year): Around $19,000
• Positioned as a budget-friendly compact SUV

MP Generation

• Starting price (2023 model year): Around $28,000
• Higher starting price, but offers more features and refinement

While the MP generation is more expensive, it offers significantly more value in terms of features, quality, and performance.

User Experiences

MK Generation

“I owned a 2010 Compass, and while it was affordable, the interior quality and performance left a lot to be desired. It felt more like a budget car than a Jeep.”[4]

MP Generation

“My 2022 Compass Trailhawk is a huge improvement over the old model. It’s comfortable, capable off-road, and feels much more premium inside.”[5]

Expert Opinions

Automotive experts have noted the significant improvements between generations:

“The transformation from the first-generation Compass to the current model is remarkable. Jeep has addressed nearly every criticism of the original, creating a competitive and desirable compact SUV.”[6]

Practical Recommendations

• If you’re considering a used Compass, the MP generation (2017+) is generally a better choice due to its improvements in quality, features, and performance.
• For those interested in off-road capability, the MP generation Trailhawk trim is significantly more capable than any MK model.
• If budget is a primary concern, a well-maintained late-model MK Compass can still offer decent value as a used vehicle, but be aware of its limitations.

Alternatives to Consider

If you’re cross-shopping the Jeep Compass, consider these alternatives:

• Honda CR-V: Better on-road performance and fuel economy
• Subaru Forester: Excellent all-wheel-drive system and reliability
• Mazda CX-5: More premium feel and engaging driving dynamics
• Toyota RAV4: Strong reliability and resale value

Conclusion

The Jeep Compass has undergone a significant transformation from the MK to MP generation. While the first-generation MK Compass was often criticized for its quality and performance, the current MP generation has addressed many of these issues, offering a more competitive and desirable compact SUV.

The MP Compass provides improved design, better performance, enhanced off-road capability, and a more premium interior. However, this comes at a higher price point. For most buyers, the improvements in the MP generation make it the better choice, especially when considering newer models with the latest updates.

Ultimately, the decision between an MK and MP Compass will depend on your budget, desired features, and how you plan to use the vehicle. If you’re looking for a modern, capable compact SUV with Jeep’s off-road heritage, the MP generation Compass is the clear winner.

FAQs

• When did Jeep switch from the MK to MP generation Compass?
  The transition from the MK to MP generation Compass occurred with the 2017 model year.
• Is the MP generation Compass more reliable than the MK?
  Generally, the MP generation has shown improved reliability compared to the MK, but long-term data is still being collected for the newest models.
• Does the MP Compass offer better fuel economy than the MK?
  Yes, the MP generation Compass, especially with its newer turbocharged engines, offers improved fuel economy compared to the MK models.
• Which generation Compass is better for off-roading?
  The MP generation, particularly in Trailhawk trim, is significantly more capable off-road than any MK model Compass.
• Are parts more expensive for the MP Compass compared to the MK?
  Parts for the MP Compass may be somewhat more expensive due to its more advanced technology and features, but this can vary depending on the specific component and market conditions.